For a sad song, there should be no beat, or drums to it. There has to be the pure feeling of how one plays the song by themselves with no other alternative for a way to make it sound "Better". The reason I gave it a 5, is all you did was pretty much modernized it. It wasnt good with the drums or the added beat, it was better in the original.

Before you assume that one will like your work, ask youself "How is this better than the first?" Or "How is this good in what way?" I am not trying to be rude. But if you want honesty, then there you go.

The original was far superior to this. But its good for the modernizer.
-MP2E

This is now not a useless review :)

Thank you for taking the time to make a second review..... That was much better and I appreciate that you explained how it deserved a 5

Bliss

Thanks man! :D